Data last verified: 20 November 2026. Figures re-checked against their primary sources under the Whito rolling re-verification programme.

Finding

Across 470 wine lists from 249 London restaurants, the percentage mark-up on the second-cheapest wine was significantly below that on the next four wines, economists at LSE and the University of Sussex found (Economics Letters, 2021).

Source: Whito, whito.co.uk/hospitality/second-cheapest-wine-restaurant-pricing, 2026-11-20. Free to quote with a link to this page.

Last Updated on November 20, 2026

Ask almost any diner and they will tell you never to order the second-cheapest wine. The story goes that restaurants know people are too embarrassed to pick the cheapest bottle, so they put their worst-value wine one line up.

Two economists checked. The story is wrong.

What the evidence says

David de Meza of the London School of Economics and Vikram Pathania of the University of Sussex sampled 249 London restaurants listed on Tripadvisor in July 2015. That gave them 470 wine lists (reds and whites counted separately) and 6,335 wines. They compared each menu price with the retail price of the same wine.

Their paper, published in Economics Letters in 2021, found that the percentage mark-up on the second-cheapest wine was significantly below the mark-up on the next four wines up the list. Percentage mark-ups peaked around the middle of the list. In the authors’ words, it is “an urban myth that the second-cheapest wine is an especially bad buy”.

They also found that the mark-up in pounds rises as you go up the list, while the mark-up in percentage terms is highest in the middle.

What restaurants and diners both assume

Diners assume the restaurant is playing a trick on line two. Some restaurateurs, having heard the same story, assume line two is where the easy margin sits.

On this evidence, London restaurants were doing something more ordinary. The authors suggest low mark-ups at the bottom encourage people to order wine at all, and high percentage mark-ups in the middle fall on the bottles most people settle for.

Our reading: the myth is now part of the market

This section is interpretation, not a finding of the study.

A diner who believes the myth skips line two. Some go down to the house wine. Others go up to line three or four, which is where the study found higher percentage mark-ups. A false belief about being overcharged may push some customers towards the bottles that carry more margin.

The wider point applies well beyond wine. Customers rarely know your costs, so they make up a story about your prices. They act on the story. A restaurant cannot stop people guessing at its motives, but it can shape what the list suggests.

Behavioural research gives two reasons the middle of a list attracts orders. People avoid extremes when they are unsure, an effect Itamar Simonson described in 1989 and called the compromise effect. And the most expensive bottles act as an anchor that makes the middle look reasonable.

What a UK restaurant can do differently

These are recommendations. The study did not test them.

  • Work out your own mark-ups by position. List your wines cheapest to dearest and put the percentage and pound mark-up beside each. Most owners have never looked at it this way.
  • Make the cheapest wine one you are happy to recommend. If staff say “the house red is good”, the embarrassment goes and so does the suspicion.
  • Do not hide value in the middle. If your best-value bottle is mid-list, say so on the menu. A customer who feels they found a fair deal comes back.
  • Watch what actually sells. If line two is selling poorly, the myth may be at work in your dining room.

The takeaway

Your customers have a theory about your prices. It may be wrong, and it still decides what they order. Check your own list before assuming where your margin comes from.

Sources and method

This is desk research, checked on 20 November 2026. Whito did not survey anyone for this article. Each figure below comes from the named source and carries its own date. Sections headed “Our reading” are interpretation, not measurement. Worked examples are illustrations with stated assumptions, not industry averages. The study covers London restaurants with wine lists online in July 2015. It may not hold for other parts of the UK, for pubs, or for today’s prices.

Related Whito research and tools

This article is part of The Business Psychology Files, Whito’s series on why UK industries behave the way they do. For the numbered research studies, see The Whito Business Files.

How to read this study

The figures show what Whito found in the sample and on the dates stated on this page. They describe the businesses, prices or answers we looked at, not every UK business. Prices and AI answers change over time. Every Whito study follows our research methodology standard. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it.

Whito logo
Jacob Whitmore
Whito is an independent UK research publisher. We publish research on how UK businesses are found, trusted and priced: what they cost to market, how their sectors work, and who actually gets recommended. Studies are free to read, every figure carries the date it was checked, and nobody pays to appear.