Data last verified: 20 November 2026. Figures re-checked against their primary sources under the Whito rolling re-verification programme.

Finding

6 million home and motor insurance policyholders would have saved £1.2 billion in 2018 had they paid the average price for their risk, the Financial Conduct Authority found.

Source: Whito, whito.co.uk/insurance-brokers/insurance-loyalty-penalty-customer-inertia, 2026-11-20. Free to quote with a link to this page.

Last Updated on November 20, 2026

In 2018, 6 million home and motor insurance customers in the UK paid more than they needed to. Had they paid the average price for their actual risk, they would have saved £1.2 billion between them. The figures are the Financial Conduct Authority’s, from its market study of general insurance pricing.

Those customers had mostly done one thing: let the policy renew.

What the evidence says

The FCA found that many firms raised prices for existing customers each year at renewal, a practice it called price walking. New customers were offered low prices, sometimes below cost. Customers who stayed paid for it later.

The regulator’s response had three main parts:

  • From January 2022, a renewing home or motor customer must be quoted a price no higher than they would get as a new customer through the same channel.
  • Firms must make it simpler to stop a policy renewing automatically.
  • Firms must consider whether their products offer fair value.

The FCA estimated these measures would save consumers £4.2 billion over ten years. It published an evaluation of how the remedies have worked in July 2025 (Evaluation Paper 25/2).

What the industry assumed

For years the working assumption was that a customer who renewed without complaint was a satisfied one. Pricing models were built on that. The longer a customer had stayed, the less likely they were to leave, and the more they could be charged.

It was profitable. It also depended on customers not looking.

Our reading: silence is a poor measure of loyalty

This section is interpretation.

Behavioural economists have long known that people stick with a default. Comparing insurance takes an evening and feels like a chore, so the renewal letter wins. The FCA’s own analysis described firms identifying the customers least likely to switch.

The business lesson reaches well beyond insurance. Any firm with repeat customers faces the same temptation: give the keen price to new customers and let the old ones drift upward. Gyms, software, broadband and trade service plans all do versions of it.

The insurance story shows where that road ends. Customers eventually find out. When they do, they do not think “I should have checked”. They think “you took advantage”. Then a regulator arrives.

What this means for insurance brokers

Brokers stood slightly apart from this, because a broker’s whole offer is checking the market on the client’s behalf. That offer is worth more now, if brokers say so.

These are recommendations, not proven results.

  • Show the renewal working. Tell the client which insurers you approached this year and what came back. A broker who shows the comparison removes the reason to go to a price comparison site.
  • Explain a price rise before the client asks. A rise with a reason is tolerated. A rise discovered later reads as price walking, whatever the cause.
  • Treat long-standing clients as the ones to protect. They are the people the old model charged most. Reviewing their cover first is the opposite signal.
  • Check your own fees for the same pattern. If new clients get a better deal than loyal ones, you have a small version of the problem the FCA banned.

The takeaway

In a single year, customers who did not look overpaid by £1.2 billion, and insurers lost the right to price that way. If part of your income depends on customers not noticing, treat it as a debt that will fall due.

Sources and method

This is desk research, checked on 20 November 2026. Whito did not survey anyone for this article. Each figure below comes from the named source and carries its own date. Sections headed “Our reading” are interpretation, not measurement. Worked examples are illustrations with stated assumptions, not industry averages. The £1.2 billion figure describes 2018, before the ban. This article does not report the findings of the FCA’s 2025 evaluation, which we have not analysed.

Related Whito research and tools

This article is part of The Business Psychology Files, Whito’s series on why UK industries behave the way they do. For the numbered research studies, see The Whito Business Files.

How to read this study

The figures show what Whito found in the sample and on the dates stated on this page. They describe the businesses, prices or answers we looked at, not every UK business. Prices and AI answers change over time. Every Whito study follows our research methodology standard. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it.