Data last verified: 20 November 2026. Figures re-checked against their primary sources under the Whito rolling re-verification programme.
Finding
In a 2006 field experiment, 34% of customers completed a 10-stamp loyalty card that came with two stamps already on it, against 19% for an 8-stamp card with none, though both needed eight purchases (Nunes and Drèze, Journal of Consumer Research).
Source: Whito, whito.co.uk/cafes/cafe-loyalty-card-head-start, 2026-11-20. Free to quote with a link to this page.
Last Updated on November 20, 2026
Read a short summary
General summary
A loyalty card that needs eight purchases can be printed two ways: eight empty boxes, or ten boxes with two already stamped. In a field experiment by Joseph Nunes and Xavier Drèze, published in 2006, 34% of customers completed the pre-stamped card against 19% for the empty one. The experiment ran at a car wash in the United States, not a UK cafe, so treat it as a strong hint and test it yourself. Our reading is that most cafe loyalty cards are designed as a discount when they work better as a sense of progress.
Bullet points
- 300 loyalty cards handed out at a US car wash; both versions needed eight paid visits (Nunes and Drèze, 2006).
- 34% completed the 10-box card with two free stamps; 19% completed the empty 8-box card.
- Customers with the head start also left less time between visits.
- The study was not run in a UK cafe. No UK cafe figure is claimed here.
- Our reading: the card’s job is to make a customer feel part-way there. This is interpretation.
Here are two loyalty cards. One has eight empty boxes: buy eight coffees, get one free. The other has ten boxes, and the first two are already stamped. It also needs eight purchases. The reward is the same and so is the cost to the cafe.
In a field experiment, nearly twice as many customers finished the second card.
What the evidence says
Joseph Nunes and Xavier Drèze handed out 300 loyalty cards at a professional car wash in the United States. Half the customers got an eight-box card. Half got a ten-box card with two stamps already added. Over nine months, 34 per cent of the head-start group completed the card and claimed the free wash, against 19 per cent of the other group. The head-start group also came back sooner between visits.
The study was published in the Journal of Consumer Research in 2006. The authors called the result the “endowed progress effect”: people work harder towards a goal when they feel they have already started.
One caution matters. This was a car wash in America twenty years ago. Nobody has shown the same numbers in a British cafe, and we are not claiming them. It is good evidence about how people respond to progress, and a reason to test the idea.
What most cafes assume
Most independent cafes treat the loyalty card as a small discount: roughly one free drink in nine or ten. On that view, the only lever is generosity. Make the card shorter and it costs more. Make it longer and nobody bothers.
The experiment suggests a third lever that costs nothing. Both cards gave away exactly the same amount. Only the framing changed.
Our reading: customers finish what they have started
This section is interpretation.
An empty card is a request: please come back eight times. A card with two stamps is a job already under way, and people dislike leaving things unfinished. The free stamps also feel like a gift, which the empty card does not offer on day one.
There is a commercial point underneath. Regulars matter to a cafe, yet many cards are handed over without a word. The moment the card is given is the one moment the cafe controls.
What a UK cafe can do differently
These are recommendations to test, not proven results.
- Reprint the card with a head start. Keep the number of paid drinks the same. Add two boxes and stamp them at the till.
- Say why. In the study the two stamps were presented as a promotion. “Two on us to get you started” is enough.
- Count completions, not cards given out. Mark the two versions differently, run both for three months and count how many of each come back full. That is your own evidence.
- Do not shorten the card to compete. If the framing does the work, you do not need to give more away.
The takeaway
A loyalty card works less like a discount and more like a progress bar. Start it part-filled, and measure whether more of your customers reach the end.
Sources and method
This is desk research, checked on 20 November 2026. Whito did not survey anyone for this article. Each figure below comes from the named source and carries its own date. Sections headed “Our reading” are interpretation, not measurement. Worked examples are illustrations with stated assumptions, not industry averages. The experiment is from the United States and from a car wash. The effect in UK cafes is untested as far as we have found.
- Nunes and Drèze, ‘The Endowed Progress Effect: How Artificial Advancement Increases Effort’, Journal of Consumer Research 32(4), 2006, pages 504 to 512 (figures read from the summary below; we could not open the journal page)
- Coglode summary of the study and its figures
- UK cafes industry hub
- Where UK cafes can save money
- UK cafe marketing data
- Break-even calculator
- Profit margin calculator
This article is part of The Business Psychology Files, Whito’s series on why UK industries behave the way they do. For the numbered research studies, see The Whito Business Files.
How to read this study
The figures show what Whito found in the sample and on the dates stated on this page. They describe the businesses, prices or answers we looked at, not every UK business. Prices and AI answers change over time. Every Whito study follows our research methodology standard. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it.


