Data last verified: 20 November 2026. Figures re-checked against their primary sources under the Whito rolling re-verification programme.
Finding
29.9% of UK mortgage borrowers in 2015 to 2016 chose a product when a cheaper one with the same key features was apparently available, paying £550 a year more on average, according to FCA Occasional Paper 33.
Source: Whito, whito.co.uk/mortgage-advisers/why-borrowers-miss-cheaper-mortgages, 2026-11-20. Free to quote with a link to this page.
Last Updated on November 20, 2026
Read a short summary
General summary
The Financial Conduct Authority studied mortgages taken out in 2015 to 2016. It found that 29.9% of borrowers chose a product when a cheaper one with the same key features was apparently available. They paid about £550 a year more on average over the introductory period. The FCA said this held whether or not the borrower used a broker, and that the market worked well in many other respects. Our reading is that borrowers stop searching once they find a deal that feels good enough from someone they trust. For mortgage advisers, showing how wide the search was is a way to earn that trust honestly. This article is not financial advice.
Bullet points
- 29.9% of borrowers in 2015 to 2016 chose a mortgage when a cheaper one with the same key features was apparently available (FCA Occasional Paper 33).
- They paid £550 a year more on average over the introductory period.
- The FCA’s Mortgages Market Study final report was published in March 2019 and found the market worked well in many respects.
- The data is now around ten years old.
- Our reading: borrowers stop at ‘good enough’. This is interpretation, and not financial advice.
Nearly one in three UK borrowers picked a mortgage when a cheaper one, with the same key features, was apparently available to them. On average they paid £550 a year more over the introductory period.
The finding comes from the Financial Conduct Authority’s Occasional Paper 33, which looked at mortgages taken out in 2015 to 2016 as part of the regulator’s Mortgages Market Study. The exact share was 29.9 per cent.
This article is about customer behaviour. It is not financial advice.
What the evidence says
The FCA compared the product each borrower chose with others they appeared to qualify for that had the same key features, such as the length of the fixed rate. Where a cheaper match existed, it counted the extra cost.
Two points from the study are easy to miss:
- The FCA’s final report, published in March 2019, said the mortgage market worked well in many respects. Most borrowers had suitable, affordable products.
- The regulator said the £550 gap appeared whether the borrower went through an intermediary or direct to a lender.
The FCA also pointed to a practical cause: the tools available did not make it easy to see which products a given borrower would qualify for.
What the industry tends to assume
Brokers often assume clients come to them for the lowest rate. Clients often assume that using a broker means the whole market has been checked. Each assumption is partly true.
Our reading: people stop at “good enough”
This section is interpretation. The FCA did not measure borrowers’ motives in this way.
The economist Herbert Simon argued in the 1950s that people faced with a hard choice do not search for the best option. They search until they find one that is good enough, then stop. He called it satisficing.
A mortgage is a hard choice made under time pressure. A house purchase has a deadline, a chain and a nervous seller. A borrower who has been offered a workable deal by someone they trust has every reason to stop looking. An adviser who has found a suitable product that will complete on time has done what the client most urgently wanted.
Nobody in that story behaves badly. The cheaper product simply goes unseen, because no one had a strong enough reason to keep looking.
Where advisers can misread their value
If clients mostly want speed and certainty, a broker who sells only on rate is selling the thing clients find hardest to check. A broker’s stronger claim is the search itself: how many lenders were considered, and why this product was chosen over the next best.
What a UK mortgage adviser can do differently
These are recommendations, not proven results, and firms must follow FCA rules in how they describe their service.
- Show the runner-up. Telling a client which product came second, and why it lost, shows that a search happened.
- Say plainly how much of the market you cover. Clients assume “whole of market”. If some lenders only deal direct, say so.
- Put the yearly cost difference in pounds. A rate difference of a fraction of a per cent means little to most people. A sum of money per year does.
- Come back before the deal ends. The client’s next search starts from you if you contact them first.
The takeaway
Borrowers do not look for the best mortgage. They look until they feel safe. The adviser who can show the search, not just the result, gives them a sound reason to feel that way.
Sources and method
This is desk research, checked on 20 November 2026. Whito did not survey anyone for this article. Each figure below comes from the named source and carries its own date. Sections headed “Our reading” are interpretation, not measurement. Worked examples are illustrations with stated assumptions, not industry averages. The FCA data covers 2015 to 2016. Sourcing tools and the market have changed since, and we have not found a more recent repeat of the analysis.
- FCA Occasional Paper No. 33, ‘Choices of dominated mortgage products by UK consumers’
- FCA Mortgages Market Study, final report MS16/2.3, March 2019
- Pinsent Masons, summary of the FCA final report
- UK mortgage advisers industry hub
- UK mortgage industry statistics
- Mortgage adviser trust signals
- How to check an FCA firm reference number
- Mortgage adviser leaderboard
This article is part of The Business Psychology Files, Whito’s series on why UK industries behave the way they do. For the numbered research studies, see The Whito Business Files.
How to read this study
The figures show what Whito found in the sample and on the dates stated on this page. They describe the businesses, prices or answers we looked at, not every UK business. Prices and AI answers change over time. Every Whito study follows our research methodology standard. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will check it.
